Visit our cake shop...Now offering a second pickup location at Hearty Pet in Hagerstown!

Birthday Cakes

We offer a fun and unique selection of personalized cakes and pawty add-ons available for special order. Select from one of our themed designs and choose your cake flavor and icing color, and add a personalized message. Our unique cakes may look like cakes for humans with fondant and buttercream icing but we DO NOT use these sugar and butter based icings. We’ve developed our own yogurt based icing to create our totally dog-friendly adorable cakes! Our cakes are soft and tender and made with our exclusive recipes using gluten-free and grain-free flours, low fat ingredients, and no butter, salt, or additional sugar.

Cakes and special order items may be picked up in store or delivered to you. We offer store pickup at our retail location inside Stay Pet in Harmans and we now have a second pickup location at Hearty Pet in Hagerstown. Our cakes are made fresh to order and will keep refrigerated for at least one week from your pickup or delivery date. All of our cakes are provided to you wrapped to keep from drying out in the refrigerator and labeled with a consume by date. We do not recommend freezing our decorated cakes because some decorations and icings will crack and separate when frozen (however freezing leftovers is fine). We provide ingredient labels and storage instructions with all of our cakes. We require a minimum 3 days notice for all cake orders. (We also stock birthday cakes in our retail freezer for walk-in purchase).

If you would like Store Pickup at our retail location inside Stay Pet you can view and select an available pickup date in your cart at checkout. You will receive an email notification when your order is complete and ready for pickup and the email contains additional information including our store address and pickup times. Your order will be ready by 10am on your selected pickup day.  We often prepare your cake order 1-2 days prior to your pickup date and we send your email notification as soon as your cake is ready so you may receive it prior to your pickup date (please check your spam folder). You are welcome to pick up your order anytime after you receive your email notification.

We now have a second Store Pickup location (for cakes and cake add-ons only) inside Hearty Pet Retail Store in Hagerstown. If you choose Hearty Pet as your pickup location, you will be sent an email notification when your order has been delivered to Hearty Pet and it is ready for pickup. Due to our delivery schedule to Hearty Pet, you may need to place your order 7-10 days in advance to ensure your desired pickup date is available (you can view and select an available pickup date in your cart at checkout). 

If you select Delivery at checkout and you need the cake by a specific date and time you will want to select a delivery date at least 1-2 days prior to the day you need it. Orders may be delivered anytime between 9am and 6pm on your delivery day and we cannot guarantee a specific delivery time.

*If you are ordering for a daycare party at Stay Pet you will need to select store pickup at checkout, select the day of the party as the pickup date, and put in the order comments that it is for a party at Stay. Your order will be provided to Stay the day of the party although you will still receive an email notification that your order is ready for pickup but you do not need to do anything further.